Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
Platforms
PCXboxPlayStationNintendo
Games
ActionStrategyRole Playing GamesSimulatorsSport Games

Game Forum / Role Playing Games / Fallout / July 2004

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

The day we all waited for....FALLOUT 3

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Duke Merc Atreides - 14 Jul 2004 18:40 GMT
Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!

BOOO YEAH

FALLOUT £
wamingo - 14 Jul 2004 19:10 GMT
> Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
>
> BOOO YEAH
>
> FALLOUT £

well, "pre"-production, at best, they only just got the license for the
title afterall...
and it's been in production 3 times before... give or take... but this time
means it could be another 2-3 years before we even see any announcements
again...
and yes it's one of those days we've all been waiting for but it's not like
we had much of a choice... and it's probably going to be near our worst
nightmare - if you don't count FBOS...
Duke Merc Atreides - 14 Jul 2004 23:11 GMT
give them a chance before you critsize
> > Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> > bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> we had much of a choice... and it's probably going to be near our worst
> nightmare - if you don't count FBOS...
wamingo - 15 Jul 2004 00:47 GMT
> give them a chance before you critsize

I think I have a fair right to critisize their intentions when their PR man
says it's not going to be drop down/isometric view "because that's not what
they do best"...

Would you like to see a 1st person shooter with the fallout title slapped on
it?

And it's not because there's something inherently wrong with 1st person
shooters, because there's not. Hell I loved morrowind for what it was worth,
but I just don't picture Fallout: A Post Apocalyptic 1st Person Shooter to
be "Fallout" at all...

Saying that though it can still turn out to be a good game despite going 1st
person.
I just think it's one hell of a bastardization of the title. It's screaming
"we make money, and get ready cos we're going to exploit this franchise to
make more - you see, 'that' is what we do best."
Homer - 14 Jul 2004 23:38 GMT
> > Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> > bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> we had much of a choice... and it's probably going to be near our worst
> nightmare - if you don't count FBOS...

This is Great! I can't wait! Where do I go to pre-order it for future
generations of my family.
Swervy_a - 15 Jul 2004 03:03 GMT
> Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
>
> BOOO YEAH
>
> FALLOUT £

Bethesda makes some great games with awesome concepts and storylines and
everything else, but they suck at getting the details right. The user
interface never seems quite polished (think of the quest manager in
Morrowind) or they leave out some trivial feature that would really make
an awesome game (like how battles in Sea Dogs take forever even at
accelerated speeds).

I would trust them perfectly if they had the rights to the
half-completed game because it's mostly the content that's missing, and
Bethesda does content great. But if they're rewriting it all, I expect
something like "The Art of Magic," which would have been so cool if the
camera had worked well.

Why the hell don't they start with what's already been done? Why do they
have to start over from scratch?

-Swervy_a
Duke Merc Atreides - 15 Jul 2004 07:43 GMT
> > Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> > bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> -Swervy_a

anyone play the terminator sreies on PC? Absolutley brilliant, top notch set
of games, no complaints at all, i keep coming back, again and again, and
while i would love to see another fallout 2, its never going to be quite the
same is it? we have waited so very long for a proper fallout 3, that lets
just see where bethesda is going to go with it before we start whinging at
them, then again if you feel that strongly, write to them or start a
petiton, let them know what the fans want, after all, they cant ignore the
fans if enough of them tell them what we want, cause we are the ones who are
going to buy it.

Black isle is dead, long live black isle.

lets see where bethesda go!
wamingo - 15 Jul 2004 13:00 GMT
> we have waited so very long for a proper fallout 3, that lets
> just see where bethesda is going to go with it before we start whinging at
> them

We're not whinging, we're discussing and speculating and giving bethesda
constructive critisism based on their announcements/PR, and that if they
don't do their job properly we'll go holy handgrenade on them.
Duke Merc Atreides - 15 Jul 2004 17:13 GMT
> > we have waited so very long for a proper fallout 3, that lets
> > just see where bethesda is going to go with it before we start whinging at
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> constructive critisism based on their announcements/PR, and that if they
> don't do their job properly we'll go holy handgrenade on them.

as long as its discusson, and not wingeing like they have on the gamespy
board!!
Bateau - 15 Jul 2004 11:17 GMT
>> Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
>> bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
>something like "The Art of Magic," which would have been so cool if the
>camera had worked well.

They leave off playtesting until it's too late to actually change
anything that sucks.

>Why the hell don't they start with what's already been done? Why do they
>have to start over from scratch?

Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Bateau - 15 Jul 2004 11:17 GMT
>Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
>bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!

No, they have bought the rights. It is not in production.
Bethesda are known for never making top down or turn based games.
Fallout 3 will be a FPS with "rpg elements".
Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Duke Merc Atreides - 15 Jul 2004 17:14 GMT
> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
>
> No, they have bought the rights. It is not in production.
> Bethesda are known for never making top down or turn based games.
> Fallout 3 will be a FPS with "rpg elements".

yes, and ian livingstone was best know for books before tombraider
Bateau - 16 Jul 2004 17:39 GMT
>> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
>> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
>yes, and ian livingstone was best know for books before tombraider

He has been designing many varied kinds of games for over 30 years.
Bethesda only make ONE kind of game - first person real time.
Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Duke Merc Atreides - 16 Jul 2004 20:42 GMT
> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> >> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> He has been designing many varied kinds of games for over 30 years.
> Bethesda only make ONE kind of game - first person real time.

think of it this way, it could have been a lot worse, NO FALLOUT 3

NOW SHUDDAP AND LET THEM WORK
wamingo - 17 Jul 2004 03:05 GMT
> think of it this way, it could have been a lot worse, NO FALLOUT 3
>
> NOW SHUDDAP AND LET THEM WORK

bethesda don't make bad games, in fact I don't even think fo3 in 1st person
will be a bad game...
And Until they start getting in financial trouble, bethesda will continue to
make top notch games...
But until otherwise announced they will all be 1st person shooters and at
best we'll see a fallouty interface...
If the license had been given to troika we could've been 95% certain it
would be made very true to the series with bird-view, TB or a TB/RT hybrid,
2d or damn good 3d or mix and all the other goodies.
Now we can be 95% certain that it won't.
Maybe YOU don't mind that, but there are those who do.

And If we shut up and let them tear the franchise apart then we can't
complain after release... so, BAAAAD idea, mmkay? ;)
rant and rave yer hearts out...
Duke Merc Atreides - 17 Jul 2004 11:51 GMT
> > think of it this way, it could have been a lot worse, NO FALLOUT 3
> >
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> complain after release... so, BAAAAD idea, mmkay? ;)
> rant and rave yer hearts out...

Now, if by rant and rave, you mean write and tell bethesda, then go for it,
just dont moan here
wamingo - 18 Jul 2004 00:48 GMT
> > And If we shut up and let them tear the franchise apart then we can't
> > complain after release... so, BAAAAD idea, mmkay? ;)
> > rant and rave yer hearts out...
>
> Now, if by rant and rave, you mean write and tell bethesda, then go for it,
> just dont moan here

And why not? really, why not?...
What good is it going to do in some endless pile of junk mail?
We may as well get a good discussion out of it here instead...

Besides look at all these posts... Almost looks as if the group is coming
alive again, how can that possibly be bad! - forget that about 50% of the
posts are mine ;)

Anyway, if you blindly trust the developers I beg you take a look at
f:bos...
Now, bethesda probably is a fair level above that standard, but if they
don't get knocked some senses into them it's likely we will be flat out
disappointed, just like with FOT. FOT which had great graphics and
atmosphere and an above average combat system, lacked just about everything
else.
Duke Merc Atreides - 18 Jul 2004 14:21 GMT
> > > And If we shut up and let them tear the franchise apart then we can't
> > > complain after release... so, BAAAAD idea, mmkay? ;)
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> atmosphere and an above average combat system, lacked just about everything
> else.

yes you make a good point Discuss,

NOT MOAN

There is a difference, but then i might just be biased seeing the crap
coming out of the gamespy boards.
Bateau - 17 Jul 2004 07:00 GMT
>> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
>> >> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
>NOW SHUDDAP AND LET THEM WORK

I really doubt this discussion is preventing them from working on the
game. Twat.
Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Duke Merc Atreides - 17 Jul 2004 11:51 GMT
> >> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> >> >> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> I really doubt this discussion is preventing them from working on the
> game. Twat.

comments like that really are not helpful, the comment is made to stop
people bitching about a game, when no details have been officially released
yet!
Richard Campbell - 17 Jul 2004 20:36 GMT
>>>>>>>Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made
>
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> people bitching about a game, when no details have been officially released
> yet!

I really hope this is untrue.  Fallout 1 and 2 are both simply the best
RPGs that ever existed.  Fallout 3 has the opportunity to be even
better.  Making it an 'fps with rpg elements' would be rather lame,
instead why don't they stick to a good 2d engine?  The things that
really drew me in about fallout 1/2 were the openness of the game, as
well as the atmosphere.  The graphics had great style, the music fit
with the game and was NEVER boring, and the game itself was just
AWESOME.  I've never played fallout tactics, but i've heard it was
pretty good too.  Turning this excellent series of RPGs into an FPS
would ruin the franchise.
Homer - 18 Jul 2004 05:06 GMT
<snip>
> >>>>>>No, they have bought the rights. It is not in production.
> >>>>>>Bethesda are known for never making top down or turn based games.
> >>>>>>Fallout 3 will be a FPS with "rpg elements".

<snip>
> I really hope this is untrue.  Fallout 1 and 2 are both simply the best
> RPGs that ever existed.  Fallout 3 has the opportunity to be even
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> pretty good too.  Turning this excellent series of RPGs into an FPS
> would ruin the franchise.

I agree. I like FPS games, but for a Fallout RPG I'd rather not have to deal
with the keyboard and mouse gymnastics involved. The turn-based combat really
worked well for the series, imho especially in FOT.

~Homer
wamingo - 18 Jul 2004 12:48 GMT
> I agree. I like FPS games, but for a Fallout RPG I'd rather not have to deal
> with the keyboard and mouse gymnastics involved. The turn-based combat really
> worked well for the series, imho especially in FOT.

I'm sorry, but I think it's safe to say that turn based is a finished
chapter for RPG's, it's not going to happen again.
Hybrids like baldurs gate's system of course are not too unlikely.
On that account, I think FOT showed us that turn-based wasn't dead
necessary, in fact seing multiple guns and explosions going off at the same
time was really pretty cool from an action-game point of view.
What do you think? I know FOT wasn't too well recieved, but was it the RT/TB
hybrid that limited its success? Because I don't think so...
oooo@oooooooooo.ooo - 19 Jul 2004 17:01 GMT
> > I agree. I like FPS games, but for a Fallout RPG I'd rather not have
> > to
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> I'm sorry, but I think it's safe to say that turn based is a finished
> chapter for RPG's, it's not going to happen again.

Why ? AFAIK there are a lot of people interested in tactical elements in
RPG (which you don't get in RT games).

> Hybrids like baldurs gate's system of course are not too unlikely.
> On that account, I think FOT showed us that turn-based wasn't dead
> necessary, in fact seing multiple guns and explosions going off at the
> same time was really pretty cool from an action-game point of view.
> What do you think? I know FOT wasn't too well recieved, but was it the
> RT/TB hybrid that limited its success? Because I don't think so...

Me neither. RT/TB is a really neat feature, like vehicles. What killed
FO:T was the comparison with FO1 & 2. You played in a known universe,
but without the openendedness you were expecting (trying killling a
brotherhood officer because you dislike your orders...), and without the
amazing details and deep storyline of the RPGs.

Would it have been released on its own, it would have been a somewhat
good post-apocalyptic UFO clone.

About Bethesda doing Fallout 3, I think we should not forget they did
Daggerfall and Morrowind, 2 rather good games. They only do 1st person
RPG, but they do it rather well. As to wether this would fit the Fallout
universe... I don't know. I guess it's the writer's job to make us
forget the original, good old 2d view with enough immersing feature.
That's a job I wouldn't like having to do. Maybe they'll add a "Fallout
Jihadists throwing stones at a game designer" random encounter in their
game :)

Signature

caffeine (at) altern :: org

Duke Merc Atreides - 19 Jul 2004 18:49 GMT
> > > I agree. I like FPS games, but for a Fallout RPG I'd rather not have
> > > to
[quoted text clipped - 34 lines]
> Jihadists throwing stones at a game designer" random encounter in their
> game :)

well, if they do do a fps, i hope they do keep random encounters, not just
monsters or scripted players!!
wamingo - 18 Jul 2004 00:21 GMT
> comments like that really are not helpful, the comment is made to stop
> people bitching about a game, when no details have been officially released
> yet!

but some details HAS been officially released!
even if it's still vague...
Bateau - 18 Jul 2004 17:13 GMT
>> >> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made
>by
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>people bitching about a game, when no details have been officially released
>yet!

Why would you try to do that? Are you a nazi?
Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Duke Merc Atreides - 18 Jul 2004 23:15 GMT
> >> >> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made
> >by
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> Why would you try to do that? Are you a nazi?

what do the national socialist workers party have to do with fallout?

Unless you are talking about the boneyard regulators!!
Connor Sterner - 19 Jul 2004 13:40 GMT
Signature

--
Looking for a date/hookup/sex partner?
http://accfq2.linksysnet.com:999/match/index2.htm

^^ Free dating services & Swingers Pages! ^^
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Need a Loan or a Credit Card?  Our loan pages are the best
http://accfq2.linksysnet.com:999/loan/index.htm

100% Guaranteed Credit Cards and Loans, EVEN IF YOU HAVE BAD CREDIT!
Also, Signature Cash advances, and debt consolidation!  Check us out today.

Looking for adult Videos? DVDs? VHS? Toys?  Look no further.
http://shop.sex-superstore.com/cgi-share/index.cgi?af=5971
Guaranteed BEST price anywhere..  $9.99 XXX DVD Section!  Free dildo with
any order over $50!  Check us out today!

> >> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> >> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 60 lines]
>               J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
>                `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Homer - 15 Jul 2004 23:38 GMT
> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
>
> No, they have bought the rights. It is not in production.
> Bethesda are known for never making top down or turn based games.
> Fallout 3 will be a FPS with "rpg elements".

Let's just hope that there are some genuine fans among the developers. I think
that to most fans the atmosphere, story, and "RPG elements" are a lot more
important than the details of the game engine and interface (as long as it
works). Also the market is full of linear style games. I hope that the path is
fairly open.

~Homer
Bateau - 16 Jul 2004 17:41 GMT
>> >Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
>> >bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator series!!
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>works). Also the market is full of linear style games. I hope that the path is
>fairly open.

The perspective has everything to do with the atmosphere.
Signature

                    .-'`-.
                   / | |  \
                  /  | |   \
                 |___|_|__  |
                 ||<o>| <o>`|
                 ||   J_   )|
                 `|`-'__`-'|/
                  |  `--'  |
                .-|        |_
             .-'  \     /  | |`-.
          .-'      `.     /| |   \
         /           ````' | |    \
        |_____             | |     L
     .-' ___   `-.         F F  |  |    ||`-.___
   .'.-'  |  `-.  `.      J J   /  |    ||    _.>
  / /|    |    |`.  \     | |   |/ |    ||_.-'
 / / |    |    |  `. `.   F F   |  |==============================
J /  |    |    |    \  L J J    |  |      `:::::::.       `:::::::.
FJ   |    |    |    |L J/ /     |   \       :::::::.        :::::::\
J |() | () | () | () | J L/      |   |        :::::::         :::::::L

| F   | .-'_ \  |    |  LJ       | /  L       ::::::::        :::::::J
| L   | /    \\ |    |  | L      |    |       ::::::::        ::::::::L
| L   ||     ):||    |  | |     /|     L      ::::::::        ::::::::|
J |   ||:._.'::||    |  | |----' |     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|     .---.
J |   |J:::::::||    |  | |    _/\     |      ::::::::        ::::::::|    /(@  o`.
LJ   | \:::::/ |    |  | |---'\  |    |      ::::::::        ::::::::|   |    /^^^
J L  |  `-:-'  |    |  | F  | \  |    J      ::::::::        ::::::::|    \ . \vvv
 LJ()| () | () | () |  F F  |  \  \--._L     ::::::::        ::::::::|     \ `--'
 J \ |    |    |    | J J     \    |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|      \ `.
  \ \|    |    |    | / /    |     |  |      ::::::::        ::::::::|       L  \
   \ \    |    |    |/ /|     |    | .-'|    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |   \
    `.`.  |    |   .'.' |     |    |/ /`L    ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    L
    | `.`-.____|.-'.-'  |     |    | <`. \   ::::::::        ::::::::|       |    |
    | | `-.______.-'    |    \|    |_`::\ `. ::::::::        ::::::::|       F    |
    | J\ |  |           |     |    /:  \::. \::::::::        ::::::::F      /     |
    |  L\|--|           |     _.--|::   `::\ `.::::::       .:::::::J      /      F
    J  J |\\|-.____     |__.-'    |:      \::. \::::        ::::::::F    .'      J
     L  \| >||      `--' J        |'      .`::\ `.:'      .::::::::/   .'        F
     J   |//JJ        |   L       |---.   .--\::. \---.   .---.   <---<         J
      L  |< |J        |\=/|       ( _  \=/  _ `::\ `.  \=/  _  \=/  _  \       /
      J  |\\|J        | | /        )_)  |  (_)  \::. \  |  (_)  |  (_)  |     /
       \ |--|J        |//\\       /    //\     //`::\ `./\     //\     /    .'
        \|  |L `      )/  )` `' '|`---//  `---//  `\::. \ `---//  `---'   .'
VK________|  L_\    '  /___/ ' |  |___//______//_____`::\ |___//_________.'_________
         F  F J``  -'|    | | |  |                    \:_|
         `-'  | ""   |    J `    |
              |      |     L     |          |\    |\          /|   /| |\     /|
              |      |     \     |          | \   | \        //   //  | \    ||  |\
              J      |      `.   |          ||\\  ||\\      //   //   ||\\   ||  ||
               L     F       )`---\         || >> || \\    / |  <<    || \\  ||  ||
               |    J        /     `.       ||//  ||  ||  //||   \\   ||  || ||  ||
               J    J       (        `-.    |//   | \ || |/ ||    \\  | \ || ||  ||
               `-.__/       `---.       `.  |<<   ||\\||    ||     >> ||\\|| ||  ||
               |   J             `.       ) ||\\  || \ |    ||    //  || \ | ||  ||
               /   |               `-----'  || >> ||  ||    ||   //   ||  ||  \\ ||
              /    F                        ||//  ||  ||    ||  <<    ||  ||   \\||
             J    J                         | /   |/  ||    |/   \\   |/  ||    \ |
             J    |                         |/        \|          \|      \|     \|
              `-.-'                         K I N G   O F   T H E   M O N S T E R S
Burning_Ranger - 20 Jul 2004 22:18 GMT
> Well its finally here, Fallout 3 is in production, it is being made by
> bethesda, also know for their amazing elder scrolls and terminator
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> FALLOUT £

I thing the fact it is is a multiplatform title will mean that horrible word
"Compromise" plays a big part in it's development.

Fallout will likely be:
-Very simplified. Most of the things that make Fallout Fallout will be gone.
No mature content. Much less dialogue. Less sidequests. Less open-ended

-It'll probably be more like that those awful games; D&D, BG:DA and the
Fallout clone that was recently released, than like Fallout 1 or 2.

-Turn based combat completely gone or at the very least heavily biased
towards real-time action (Morrowind has many good things, but it's combat
system is perhaps one of the worst ever in a RPG)

Woudn't get too excited until some game screenshots or further details are
released. Don't get me wrong I love Fallout 1 and 2 and all of Bioware/Black
Isle's PC RPGs more than anything, but if current trends are anything to go
by, Fallout 3 will NOT be what we all hope it will be.

Bugger.

--

Burning_Ranger
Homer - 21 Jul 2004 02:28 GMT
> I thing the fact it is is a multiplatform title will mean that horrible word
> "Compromise" plays a big part in it's development.
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> Burning_Ranger

Deja vu all over again:

Here is what was being discussed a year ago...

(copied from July 7 2003 post)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Roger Aario wrote:
> "Filip van den Bergh"  wrote in message
> news:be3f89$ql09$1@ID-171954.news.dfncis.de...
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> What does that mean exactly?  Will there be a full turn-based
> mode or will it be hybridized ala the Bioware D&D games?

The drift appears a FO for everyone, including consoles.

It is openly discussed that those that make all the important
'marketing' decisions are wanting to see a flavor of "real time".

The general drift of FO system changes by JE of BIS is everything is
negociable. JE has a lot of ideas and it's an interesting read.

Expect changes.... <deleted>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Does this mean that in May 2005 we will be discussing the demise of Bethesda?

~Homer
Who hopes to be playing TB, Top-down, Faithful to the Bible (Gospel according to
Saint Chris), Open-ended, Side-questing, Mature-content-capable, Fallout 3 in
2005.
Burning_Ranger - 21 Jul 2004 18:42 GMT
>>>> No mutants allowed has an interview with one of the creative
>>>> producers of a project titled Van Buren.
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> The general drift of FO system changes by JE of BIS is everything is
> negociable. JE has a lot of ideas and it's an interesting read.

That Van Buren was a different game was it not? Not related to Fallout.

--

Burning_Ranger
Homer - 22 Jul 2004 02:56 GMT
> >>>> No mutants allowed has an interview with one of the creative
> >>>> producers of a project titled Van Buren. <deleted>
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Burning_Ranger

"Van Buren" was Black Isle's project name for Fallout 3. About a year ago it was
in development and the dicussion was uncannily similar to what we have now. It
seemed to be moving along pretty well until Interplay self-destructed...

http://www.nma-fallout.com/content.php?page=fo3-history

Here's the screenshot from when hope ended in December '03:

http://www.nma-fallout.com/fallout3/fo3mm.png
4too - 22 Jul 2004 14:42 GMT
>>>>>>No mutants allowed has an interview with one of the creative
>>>>>>producers of a project titled Van Buren. <deleted>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> http://www.nma-fallout.com/fallout3/fo3mm.png

The news announcements of FO:BOS and Van Buren,  and the subsequent
activity on the FO, RPG, and all inclusive, fan sites might be a
constructive comparison on sending dev's out to publicize a game in
progress.

If one had an academic "arcane foot notation" mindset or a
sports-journalistic "thrill of victory" fervor, one might be able to
pick apart the performance of the lead men, and the value of timing,
[such as which launched first (FO:BOS)], and the power of personality
and style.

My impression is that "JE et al", JE (Sawyer) - and all -  the dev's on
the VB team (Puuk and Briarenus come to mind) did an excellent job in
meeting the demands for information and selling their image on how the
game would look and play.  'JE et al' sold a "FO" sequal, not a FO2 mod,
that would - challenge - the FO veterans.

VB to this day, if one polled opinions, persona to persona, at NMA and
DAC, a full spectrum from enthusiasm to rejection would be apparent, AND
possibley a universal call of "" bring it on "".

One of the best reads was a JE persona (ropekid) led discussion at SA,
(Something Awful).  SA at that time was a neutral turf or country, like
 a Switzerland, where FO fans of all persuasions could witness the
varied opinions of another group of "play'ah's".

This contrasts to the more recent flurry of flamers that have been
bouncing from website to website at the news of Bethesda getting the FO
license.  The moral tone was more like what was gushing about FO:BOS.
Each domain- FO - Morrowind/TES - and - SA has their own sub sets of
competitive purveyors of baiting negativity.

Image if there was an Warcraft/Warlords RTS game adapted to a RPG
format, based on the Land Of OZ, and each compass point had their
respective flavor of witch.  It is now time to pack up your ToTo and
march your tin man, lion, and scarecrow to the next fed ex drop off
before the 4 or more colors of flying monkeys fill up the band width.

It may be safe now to go to these sites and see discourse on
FO3-B(Bethesda) without the tedious text crunching of page after page of
broken record arguments, and the weary hooks of trolls.

A quick run through might bring one up to speed with the 'buzz', so
whenever something real emerges one can see where each fount of opinion
springs from.

4too
Darin Johnson - 21 Jul 2004 03:36 GMT
> I thing the fact it is is a multiplatform title will mean that horrible word
> "Compromise" plays a big part in it's development.
>
> Fallout will likely be:
> -Very simplified. Most of the things that make Fallout Fallout will be gone.
> No mature content. Much less dialogue. Less sidequests. Less open-ended

Not necessarily true.  There are tons of games on consoles with over
the top mature content.  Fallout 2 is demure compared to some.
Knights of the Old Republic had tons of sidequests and dialogue.  Deus
Ex 2 was full of talking most of the time.  Morrowind was so open
ended that many people fell off completely.

You're essentially prejudging the game before it's even been designed.
There are good games out there for both PC and consoles that were not
dumbed down or simplified (Thief 3, Morrowind, KOTOR), and they won't
be the last.

Signature

Darin Johnson
   Support your right to own gnus.

Burning_Ranger - 21 Jul 2004 18:40 GMT
>> I thing the fact it is is a multiplatform title will mean that
>> horrible word "Compromise" plays a big part in it's development.
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Not necessarily true.  There are tons of games on consoles with over
> the top mature content.

When I say 'mature' I don't mean adult rated. The violence and sex in GTA is
adult rated, but it is not what you would call mature, it's extremely
childish. A game can have mature content without having any explicit
violence or sexual themes. Look at PlaneScape: Torment, not exactly full of
violence and sex but probably one of the more mature games out there. The
Fallout: BOS game on consoles is an example of adult content that is
immature.

> Fallout 2 is demure compared to some.
> Knights of the Old Republic had tons of sidequests and dialogue

Played it, finished it. Maybe I'm spoilt by the likes of Baldur's Gate and
fallout but I found Knights of the Old Republic very restrictive, the areas
to explore felt way too small and didn't have that many sidequests (compared
to Bioware's other RPGs at least). It felt like 'light' RPG.

> Deus
> Ex 2 was full of talking most of the time.

I've played Deus Ex 1 and 2. I would say both are FPSs with a a few RPG
elements. But they are still both shooters. I can't remember there being
THAT much dialogue in Deus Ex 2.

>Morrowind was so open
> ended that many people fell off completely.

Yes, it really did go to show that a almost completely open-ended RPG is
possible. One of my favourite games, but awful awful combat. But still a
fantastic game.

> You're essentially prejudging the game before it's even been designed.

Well yes of course, but based on current and past trends I'd say my
pre-judging is going to turn out more correct than incorrect. Unfortunately.

> There are good games out there for both PC and consoles that were not
> dumbed down or simplified (Thief 3, Morrowind, KOTOR), and they won't
> be the last.

Only two of those are proper RPGs, and KOTOR doesn't have a prequel for one
to compare it to. It's the first in it's series, if it was an action game it
would be judged as an action game, it IS a fairly simple RPG as thus it is
judged as a fairly simple RPG. If Fallout 3 was an original creation insted
of a sequel, no one would have any expectations of it, but as it is it's the
sequel to two of the best RPGs ever made and has a lot to live up to.

--

Burning_Ranger
Darin Johnson - 21 Jul 2004 22:59 GMT
> When I say 'mature' I don't mean adult rated. The violence and sex in GTA is
> adult rated, but it is not what you would call mature, it's extremely
> childish.

You mean like the drugs and porn in Fallout 2?

Signature

Darin Johnson
   Gravity is a harsh mistress -- The Tick

Duke Merc Atreides - 22 Jul 2004 10:43 GMT
> > When I say 'mature' I don't mean adult rated. The violence and sex in GTA is
> > adult rated, but it is not what you would call mature, it's extremely
> > childish.
>
> You mean like the drugs and porn in Fallout 2?

i think hes talking more of the moral and ethical choices
Burning_Ranger - 22 Jul 2004 13:53 GMT
>>> When I say 'mature' I don't mean adult rated. The violence and sex
>>> in GTA is adult rated, but it is not what you would call mature,
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> i think hes talking more of the moral and ethical choices

Exactly. Most games are like GTA, a kid's version of morality with black &
whtie concepts of right and wrong, without repercussions of any sort. Games
like Fallout on the other hand have moralistic stories where helping one
person can result in the death of someone else. This is what roleplaying is
about after all; repercussions.

--

Burning_Ranger

To email: aziz@aziz1removethisbit.fsnet.co.uk
François Grandjean - 22 Jul 2004 17:08 GMT
>>>>When I say 'mature' I don't mean adult rated. The violence and sex
>>>>in GTA is adult rated, but it is not what you would call mature,
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> person can result in the death of someone else. This is what roleplaying is
> about after all; repercussions.

Except that for Fallout you had writers behind who wanted to give that
kind of choices, GTA games were created with having fun doing illegal
things in mind and not in a serious manner. Games such as Planescape:
Torment or Fallout have different purposes and different ways to
approach adult themes (and it may not mean something illegal or sexual
but something of philosophical nature).
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.